The Barbershop: Dennis Byrne, Proprietor
What does the science REALLY say about the benefits of children wearing masks in school?
Chicago Tribune file.
No proven benefit
Panicked governors and school boards are rushing ahead with “mandates” requiring students to wear masks. Sadly, the assumed benefits are not supported by science.
A recent, lengthy and solidly reported story in New York magazine’s Intelligencer by DavidZweig concludes that, “The science of masking kids at school remains uncertain.”
At the end of May, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention published a notable, yet mostly ignored, large-scale study of COVID transmission in American schools. A few major news outlets covered its release by briefly reiterating the study’s summary: that masking then-unvaccinated teachers and improving ventilation with more fresh air were associated with a lower incidence of the virus in schools. Those are common-sense measures, and the fact that they seem to work is reassuring but not surprising.
Other findings of equal importance in the study, however, were absent from the summary and not widely reported. These findings cast doubt on the impact of many of the most common mitigation measures in American schools. Distancing, hybrid models, classroom barriers, HEPA filters, and, most notably, requiring student masking were each found to not have a statistically significant benefit. In other words, these measures could not be said to be effective.
In the realm of science and public-health policy outside the U.S., the implications of these particular findings are not exactly controversial. Many of America’s peer nations around the world — including the U.K., Ireland, all of Scandinavia, France, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and Italy — have exempted kids, with varying age cutoffs…
These countries, along with the World Health Organization, whose child-masking guidance differs substantially from the CDC’s recommendations, have explicitly recognized that the decision to mask students carries with it potential academic and social harms for children and may lack a clear benefit. To date, the highly transmissible Delta variant has not led them to change this calculus….
The study published by the CDC was both ambitious and groundbreaking. It covered more than 90,000 elementary-school students in 169 Georgia schools from November 16 to December 11 and was, according to the CDC, the first of its kind to compare COVID-19 incidence in schools with certain mitigation measures in place to other schools without those measures. Scientists I spoke with believe that the decision not to include the null effects of a student masking requirement (and distancing, hybrid models, etc.) in the summary amounted to “file drawering” these findings, a term researchers use for the practice of burying studies that don’t produce statistically significant results. [My emphasis.]
There’s no comparable, robust study, according to Zweig. He notes that “The closest is a study published in Science, based on a Facebook survey, that was suggestive but not conclusive of a marginal benefit of student masking,”
How to say this so that the anti-science partisans understand it?: No persuasive study shows there’s a benefit to young adults masking in school.
Doesn’t matter. I will be instructed by the blindly partisan that “science” says otherwise. Another sad and threadbare appeal to supposed authority.
Filed under:
Uncategorized
Tags:
school covid masks
Welcome to ChicagoNow.
Visit my new website
I’m a freelance writer, editor and author. I can help you with a wide variety of projects. Check out my new website at www.dennisbyrne.net
Subscribe to The Barbershop
Enter your email address:
Delivered by FeedBurner
Dennis Byrne’s Facebook Fan Page
Blogroll
Blithe Spirit
Center for Media and Public Affiars
Chicago Daily Observer
Forgotten Chicago
Pat Hickey’s “With Both Hands”
QT brought to you by Zay Smith
Like me on Facebook
Blogroll
Blithe Spirit
Assorted commentary offered in lieu of organized commentary that is not yet organized
Center for Media and Public Affiars
Chicago Daily Observer
Intelligent commentary about Chicago politics
Forgotten Chicago
A great site featuring what Chicago used to be and how it got to what it is now.
Pat Hickey’s “With Both Hands”
QT brought to you by Zay Smith
Chicago’s wittiest columnist
Our National Debt
Tags
politics (269)
Illinois (166)
Chicago (157)
Obama (105)
COVID-19 (89)
Barack Obama (76)
Obamacare (72)
elections (69)
Donald Trump (66)
health care (62)
Recent Comments
jnorto
30 minutes ago
Richard Davis
44 minutes ago
Aquinas wired
59 minutes ago
Aquinas wired
1 hour, 3 minutes ago
Dennis Byrne
1 hour, 21 minutes ago
Recent posts
What does the science REALLY say about the benefits of children wearing masks in school? »
Hello, trolls »
The never-ending pandemic. How do we know when it’s over? »
Americans shellack Biden for botched Afghan surrender. »
FBI finds scant evidence Jan. 6 was coordinated. MSNBC host: It’s bad news for Trump »
Latest on ChicagoNow
What does the science REALLY say about the benefits of children wearing masks in school?
posted today at 2:15 pm
Hello, trolls
posted today at 12:49 pm
Summer chairs
posted today at 11:41 am
Pluto, I hardly knew ye. Hurroo, Hurroo
posted today at 9:30 am
The never-ending pandemic. How do we know when it’s over?
posted today at 9:08 am
Posts from related blogs
The Quark In The Road
Most recent post: Pluto, I hardly knew ye. Hurroo, Hurroo
The Patriotic Dissenter
Most recent post: Rise of Cryptocurrency Enables Explosion of Ransomware Attacks
The Chicago Board of Tirade
Most recent post: The MeidasTouch ad Fox doesn’t want you to see
More from News: Opinion
Read these ChicagoNow blogs
Cubs Den
Pets in need of homes
Hammervision
Read these ChicagoNow Bloggers
Carole Kuhrt Brewer
Dennis Byrne
LeaGrover
About ChicagoNow
•
FAQs
•
Advertise
•
Recent posts RSS
•
Privacy policy (Updated)
•
Comment policy
•
Terms of service
•
Chicago Tribune Archives
•
Do not sell my personal info
©2021 CTMG – A Chicago Tribune website –
Crafted by the News Apps team
Leave a comment