The Barbershop: Dennis Byrne, Proprietor
Back by (un)popular demand, the Florida vs. Illinois pandemic score card
Crowds cool off along the lakefront near Diversey Parkway on July 14, 2020. (E. Jason Wambsgans / Chicago Tribune)
This column appeared today in the Chicago Tribune
By Dennis Byrne
After this headline, “Sorry, Illinois, but Florida is doing this reopening thing right,” appeared above my May 8 chattering in this space, emails began showing up. “Dear Moron,” one opened. Another closed, “here’s hoping that you and your family die.” In between, an assortment of slurs, aspersions and denunciations arrived. Some quite clever.
The volume only increased as Florida, along with other states, began experiencing more new cases. Especially Florida, where experts declared that the Miami area was now the world’s pandemic “epicenter.”
Some emails even sounded gleeful that Florida’s caseload was spiking. Never mind the humanity. Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot was right, they said, when she gave it to Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis’ “fumbling” by reopening the beaches. “God help us all,” she intoned.” A Twitter hashtag, #floridamorons, piled on.
Well, there’s this:
As of Wednesday morning, cumulative deaths attributed to COVID-19 are: Illinois, 7,218; Florida, 4,409, according to the Illinois Department of Public Health and the Florida Department of Health, respectively.
Florida’s population of 21.48 million is almost double of Illinois’ 12.67 million. Yet Illinois has suffered 2,809 more deaths than Florida. Maybe Florida has been doing something right.
Critics now will fill my inbox with more directives, explaining why new cases, hospitalizations, test results and other data are more important than deaths.
But deaths are the key statistic. It’s the ultimate failure, the tragedy that causes the most pain, for the patient, family and the heroic health care providers. It’s the loss of a life.
I didn’t start this grudge match about who got it right, or who’s to blame. I was asked to respond when Lightfoot butted in, uninvited, while her own lockdown regulations were just as questionable as DeSantis’. A case in point: the lengthy closing of the lakefront to walkers and bikers when science says the risk of transmission is lower outdoors. Follow the science? Bah. Lightfoot is as qualified to judge what other states do as President Donald Trump is to brag that he can halt the violence in Chicago.
Truth is that no one knew from the start how to deal with the novel coronavirus. Not Trump. Not his Democratic, progressive or woke critics. And clearly not the epidemiologists who seem to have gotten so much wrong. Yet, they still want us to take their warnings as biblical. When they can’t accurately count the infected or calculate the fatality rate.
I could say that Miami’s troubling increase in new cases is the result of all those Democrats from New York and Chicago who fled their own epicenters and brought the disease (and their woke politics) with them. But I can’t; I don’t know. Certainly, the hypothesis that interstate travel was as significant as the arrival of infected travelers from China and Europe deserves study. I suspect a federal grant already is in the works.
We all have been stumbling around, and too many are letting their partisanship, self-interest or ego rule. What we should be learning — among many lessons — is that “science” is fragile and fallible. Especially today’s “end-of-the-world-as-we-know-it” science. Science, as demonstrated by our struggle to understand and deal with the unique coronavirus and COVID-19, sometimes is fouled by incomplete or poorly collected data, unproven hypotheses and, simply, wild guesses. Automatically accepting “science” findings as a done deal is a fool’s game.
Even worse is the assumption that “infallible science” can’t be challenged by or balanced with other policy considerations. Most notably missing in this equation is the impact of the pandemic lockdown on jobs and the economy. A truly scientific approach would weigh the epidemiologists’ policies as compared with rigorous scholarship about their negative, even dangerous, impacts on the economy. What is the calculus, for example, on whether the psychological and learning damage from keeping children out of school is more destructive than their transmission of the virus? Sadly, asking this question will get you assigned as a Trump supporter who cares only about the stock market.
So far, Lightfoot has demonstrated a troubling grasp of how to balance health and economic needs. Gov. J.B. Pritzker, a billionaire with no firsthand acquaintance with checking accounts drying up and pink slips arriving, has demonstrated that he hasn’t an inkling about the misery that he has caused.
So, in Lightfoot’s words, “God help us.”
My historical novel: Madness: The War of 1812
To subscribe to the Barbershop, type your email address in the box and click the “create subscription” button. My list is completely spam free, and you can opt out at any time.
Filed under:
Health, Illinois politics
Tags:
Coronavirus, COVID-19, Florida, J. B. Pritzker
-
Advertisement:
-
Advertisement:
-
Welcome to ChicagoNow.
-
-
Visit my new website
I’m a freelance writer, editor and author. I can help you with a wide variety of projects. Check out my new website at www.dennisbyrne.net
-
Subscribe to The Barbershop
Enter your email address:
Delivered by FeedBurner
-
Dennis Byrne’s Facebook Fan Page
[embedded content] -
Blogroll
The Barbershop: Dennis Byrne, Proprietor’s favorite blogs -
Like me on Facebook
[embedded content] -
Blogroll
The Barbershop: Dennis Byrne, Proprietor’s favorite blogs- Blithe Spirit
Assorted commentary offered in lieu of organized commentary that is not yet organized - Center for Media and Public Affiars
- Chicago Daily Observer
Intelligent commentary about Chicago politics - Forgotten Chicago
A great site featuring what Chicago used to be and how it got to what it is now. - Pat Hickey’s “With Both Hands”
- QT brought to you by Zay Smith
Chicago’s wittiest columnist
- Blithe Spirit
-
Our National Debt
-
Twitter
-
Tags
- politics (269)
- Illinois (164)
- Chicago (157)
- Obama (105)
- Barack Obama (76)
- Obamacare (71)
- elections (69)
- Donald Trump (65)
- health care (62)
- Democrats (62)
-
Recent Comments
-
You did not talk about when the body count in Florida catches up with that in Illinois. I notice…
-

Dennis Byrne
7 hours, 54 minutes ago
And you’re back to your same old effort to create a stratman. I did not say nor do I claim… -
jnorto
8 hours, 5 minutes ago
Back to your same old thesis–only the body counts matter. The ill are irrelevant. But even if we accept… -
Get out of IL now!
8 hours, 17 minutes ago
As a health care provider for over 40 years, you are 100% correct about the idea that “science” is fallible… -
Lincoln311
1 day, 3 hours ago
112 people dead in Florida today from Covid19. Only 8 in Illinois. If only the pizookies weren’t so…
-
-
-
/Users/dennisby/Desktop/trailer.mp4
-
Recent posts
-
Back by (un)popular demand, the Florida vs. Illinois pandemic score card »
Dennis Byrne on The Barbershop: Dennis Byrne, ProprietorPosted today at 3:07 pm -
Trump did Sessions wrong; Sessions comes out as the better man »
Dennis Byrne on The Barbershop: Dennis Byrne, ProprietorPosted Tuesday at 9:25 pm -
Your kids are being conscripted into an anti-Trump Children’s Crusade »
Dennis Byrne on The Barbershop: Dennis Byrne, ProprietorPosted July 10, 2020 at 9:22 am -
Chicago bigshots to South Side and south suburbs: Screw you »
Dennis Byrne on The Barbershop: Dennis Byrne, ProprietorPosted July 7, 2020 at 2:57 pm -
Gather your courage and speak out. It’s a sacred freedom »
Dennis Byrne on The Barbershop: Dennis Byrne, ProprietorPosted July 5, 2020 at 12:49 pm
-
-
Latest on ChicagoNow
-
How Siblings Inspire Success – A Tribute to My Brothers
from Success Stories by Success Junkie
posted today at 9:01 pm -
Dear Mask resisters: Put on the damned mask and shut the hell up
from When You Put It That Way by Teppi Jacobsen
posted today at 7:48 pm -
Movie Review: Palm Springs
from Hammervision by John Hammerle
posted today at 5:45 pm -
Being forced to stay inside forced me to “go inside” — and write this song
from Where Are We Going So Fast? by James Warda
posted today at 4:42 pm -
Back by (un)popular demand, the Florida vs. Illinois pandemic score card
from The Barbershop: Dennis Byrne, Proprietor by Dennis Byrne
posted today at 3:07 pm
-
-
Posts from related blogs
-
When You Put It That Way
Most recent post: Dear Mask resisters: Put on the damned mask and shut the hell up
-
The Patriotic Dissenter
Most recent post: 2020 MLB Season Defined by Individuals Taking Personal Reponsibility
-
Margaret Serious
Most recent post: Thoughts on six years as a blogger
More from News: Opinion
-
-
Read these ChicagoNow blogs
-

Cubs Den
Chicago Cubs news and comprehensive blog, featuring old school baseball writing combined with the latest statistical trends -

Pets in need of homes
Pets available for adoption in the Chicago area -

Show Me Chicago
Show Me Chicago previews, reviews and expresses opinions on what’s happening in Chicago from Blockbuster Theater, to what’s new in dining, arts, and the neighborhoods.
-
-
Read these ChicagoNow Bloggers
-

John Hammerle
from Hammervision: -

Natalie Matthews
from Aspiring Dance Mom: -

Dennis Byrne
-
-
Advertisement:
- About ChicagoNow
- •
- FAQs
- •
- Advertise
- •
- Recent posts RSS
- •
- Privacy policy (Updated)
- •
- Comment policy
- •
- Terms of service
- •
- Chicago Tribune Archives
- •
- Chicago Internet Marketing Services
©2020 CTMG – A Chicago Tribune website –
Crafted by the News Apps team


4 comments